29 May 2014

3rd Round

NY Cosmos

2 : 0

Finished

Brooklyn Italians

Belson Stadium at St John's University, Queens, New York

15 Jun 2014

4th Round

NY Cosmos

3 : 0

Finished

New York Red Bulls

James M. Shuart Stadium, Hempstead, New York

25 Jun 2014

5th Round

Philadelphia Union

2 : 1

Finished (AET)

NY Cosmos

PPL Park, Chester, Pennsylvania

28 May 2015

3rd Round

NY Cosmos

3 : 0

Finished

Jersey Express

Belson Stadium at St John's University, Queens, New York

18 Jun 2015

4th Round

NY Cosmos

4 : 4

Finished (PEN)

New York City FC

James M. Shuart Stadium, Hempstead, New York

02 Jul 2015

5th Round

New York Red Bulls

4 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

Red Bull Arena, Harrison, New Jersey

02 Jun 2016

3rd Round

NY Cosmos

2 : 0

Finished

Jersey Express

Belson Stadium at St John's University (Queens, New York)

16 Jun 2016

4th Round

New York City FC

0 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

Jack Coffey Field (Bronx, New York)

30 Jun 2016

8th Finals

NY Cosmos

2 : 3

Finished

New England Revolution

Belson Stadium at St John's University (Queens, New York)

18 May 2017

2nd Round

Reading United

3 : 2

Finished

NY Cosmos

Gene L. Shirk Stadium (Reading, Pennsylvania)

09 May 2019

1st Round

NY Cosmos

2 : 1

Finished

Black Rock

Rocco B. Commisso Soccer Stadium (New York City)

15 May 2019

2nd Round

Hartford Athletic

2 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

Al-Marzook Athletic Fields (Hartford, Connecticut)

16 Aug 2020

Fall Season Phase 1 – 1

NY Cosmos

1 : 1

Finished

Michigan Stars

Mitchel Athletic Complex, Garden City, New York

22 Aug 2020

Fall Season Phase 1 – 2

New Amsterdam

1 : 3

Finished

NY Cosmos

Hudson Sports Complex, Warwick, New York

10 Sep 2020

Fall Season Phase 1 – 2

NY Cosmos

0 : 0

Finished

Detroit City

Mitchel Athletic Complex, Garden City, New York

13 Sep 2020

Fall Season Phase 1 – 2

Chattanooga

2 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

Finley Stadium, Chattanooga, Tennessee

23 Sep 2020

Fall Season Phase 2 – 2

California Utd Strikers

2 : 0

Finished

NY Cosmos

Keyworth Stadium, Hamtramck, Michigan

26 Sep 2020

Fall Season Phase 2 – 2

Chattanooga

0 : 0

Finished

NY Cosmos

Keyworth Stadium, Hamtramck, Michigan

29 Sep 2020

Fall Season Phase 2 – 2

NY Cosmos

1 : 2

Finished

LA Force

Keyworth Stadium, Hamtramck, Michigan

14 Mar 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

1 : 3

Finished

Portland Hearts of Pine

Hinchliffe Stadium

21 Mar 2026

Group Stage

Spokane Velocity

3 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

One Spokane Stadium

26 Mar 2026

Group Stage

Greenville Triumph

3 : 2

Finished

NY Cosmos

Paladin Stadium

28 Mar 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

2 : 0

Finished

Fort Wayne

Hinchliffe Stadium

04 Apr 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

3 : 2

Finished

Charlotte Independence

Hinchliffe Stadium

19 Apr 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

2 : 2

Finished

Forward Madison

Hinchliffe Stadium

25 Apr 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

0 : 3

Finished

Brooklyn

Hinchliffe Stadium

03 May 2026

Group Stage

Portland Hearts of Pine

3 : 1

Finished

NY Cosmos

Fitzpatrick Stadium

16 May 2026

Group Stage

Westchester SC

2 : 3

Finished

NY Cosmos

The Stadium at Memorial Field

24 May 2026

Group Stage

Alta

4 : 0

Finished

NY Cosmos

Lancaster Municipal Stadium

28 May 2026

Group Stage

NY Cosmos

1 : 2

Finished

Union Omaha

Hinchliffe Stadium