Team

22 Mar 2024

1st Round

Steel City

0 : 1

Finished

Michigan Stars

Ambrose Urbanic Field, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

12 May 2024

Midwest – 1

Flower City Union

0 : 3

Finished

Steel City

Marina Auto Stadium, Rochester, New York

19 May 2024

Midwest – 3

Steel City

5 : 0

Finished

Flower City Union

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

26 May 2024

Midwest – 3

Erie Commodores

1 : 1

Finished

Steel City

Mercyhurst University Tulio Field, Erie, Pennsylvania

01 Jun 2024

Midwest – 5

Akron City

1 : 2

Finished

Steel City

Stadium at St. Vincent – St. Mary High School, Akron, Ohio

03 Jun 2024

Midwest – 6

Niagara 1812

1 : 5

Finished

Steel City

Dobson Field, Buffalo, New York

09 Jun 2024

Midwest – 6

Steel City

2 : 0

Finished

Cleveland SC

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

15 Jun 2024

Midwest – 8

SI Guardians

0 : 5

Finished

Steel City

Floyd Central HS Football Stadium, Floyds Knobs, Indiana

24 Jun 2024

Midwest – 10

Steel City

2 : 2

Finished

Erie Commodores

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

30 Jun 2024

Midwest – 12

Steel City

3 : 3

Finished

Michigan Rangers

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

06 Jul 2024

Midwest – 13

Steel City

8 : 0

Finished

Niagara 1812

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

11 Jul 2024

Conference – Semi-finals

Steel City

3 : 2

Finished

Flower City Union

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

14 Jul 2024

Conference – Finals

Steel City

2 : 0

Finished

Akron City

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

21 Jul 2024

Regional Finals

Steel City

2 : 3

Finished (AET)

Duluth

Graham Field, Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania

18 May 2025

Central Conference – 2

Akron City

2 : 2

Finished

Steel City

Stadium at St. Vincent – St. Mary High School, Akron, Ohio

22 May 2025

Central Conference – 3

Steel City

2 : 1

Finished

Buffalo

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

24 May 2025

Central Conference – 4

Erie Sports Center

1 : 2

Finished

Steel City

Penn State Behrend Turf Field, Erie, Pennsylvania

29 May 2025

Central Conference – 5

Toledo Villa

2 : 1

Finished

Steel City

Paul Hotmer Field, Toledo, Ohio

06 Jun 2025

Central Conference – 6

Steel City

2 : 0

Finished

Cleveland Force

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

07 Jun 2025

Central Conference – 7

Steel City

4 : 0

Finished

Erie Sports Center

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

20 Jun 2025

Central Conference – 12

Toledo Villa

2 : 3

Finished

Steel City

Paul Hotmer Field, Toledo, Ohio

26 Jun 2025

Central Conference – 13

Buffalo

1 : 4

Finished

Steel City

Coyer Field, Buffalo, New York

29 Jun 2025

Central Conference – 15

Steel City

1 : 1

Finished

Akron City

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

03 Jul 2025

Central Conference – 16

Steel City

0 : 0

Finished

Buffalo

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

07 Jul 2025

Central Conference – 17

Steel City

2 : 1

Finished

Toledo Villa

Founders Field, Cheswick, Pennsylvania

13 Jul 2025

Central Conference – 19

Cleveland Force

1 : 3

Finished

Steel City

Krenzler Field, Cleveland, Ohio

19 Jul 2025

Conference – Quarter-finals

Flint City Bucks

4 : 3

Finished

Steel City

Atwood Stadium, Flint, Michigan

26 Mar 2026

Round of 128

Pittsburgh Riverhounds

2 : 1

Finished

Steel City

Highmark Stadium

21 May 2026

Group Stage

Steel City

0 : 0

Finished

Lorain County Leviathan

28 May 2026

Group Stage

Pittsburgh Riverhounds 2

0 : 2

Finished

Steel City